Meet the Team
At Old Carter Barn, we take pride in curating unique, one-of-a-kind weddings. Every wedding here is a special and cherished occasion from intimate ceremonies to glamorous celebrations. Whatever your size and style, we’re honored to be a part of your story.
Dave Maxey – Venue Manager
Dave Maxey
Venue Manager
Dave Maxey is the heart and soul of Old Carter Barn, ensuring every event runs smoothly from start to finish. As our venue manager, he works closely with couples to bring their wedding vision to life, handling everything from coordinating the ceremony to lighting the fire pit and making sure guests are well cared for. On your big day, Dave is the “captain of the ship,” keeping things on schedule and handling any surprises with ease. Dave has been with Old Carter Barn since its renovation, lending his craftsmanship to the property’s stunning stonework, including the patio and entrance ramp. A proud Montrose native and dedicated father of two boys, he brings both skill and heart to everything he does.
LEWIS FLINN – Owner
LEWIS FLINN
Owner
Lewis Flinn is the creative force behind Old Carter Barn, overseeing its design and renovation to transform it into the stunning venue it is today. He manages all wedding contracts and onboarding, working closely with Dave Maxey on event staffing, barn improvements, and social media. With a background as a renowned music composer-having had shows on Broadway and across the country-Lewis approaches each wedding like a theatrical production, ensuring every detail is perfectly orchestrated. Believing that weddings are among the most important days in a couple’s life, Lewis is dedicated to making sure Old Carter Barn delivers a truly unforgettable experience. Splitting his time between Pennsylvania and New York City with his husband, Douglas Carter Beane, he often stops by to greet couples and lend a hand on wedding days.
DOUGLAS CARTER BEANE- Owner
DOUGLAS CARTER BEANE
Owner
For Douglas Carter Beane, Old Carter Barn is more than just a wedding venue-it’s part of his family’s legacy. His grandparents purchased the property in 1951, and his mother grew up in the farmhouse while his grandfather ran the land as a turkey farm until the late 1960s. Now, Doug and his husband, Lewis Flinn, have reimagined the barn as a space for celebrations, bringing new life to this historic property. An acclaimed playwright and screenwriter, Doug has earned five Tony Award nominations for his work on Broadway. His storytelling background brings a unique perspective to Old Carter Barn, ensuring that every wedding becomes part of its rich and evolving history. Splitting his time between Pennsylvania and New York City, Doug remains deeply connected to the barn and its past while helping couples create unforgettable new memories.
History of Old Carter Barn
Rustic and refined, this historic barn at Old Carter Farm overlooks scenic Lake Carey- 5 miles north of Tunkhannock, PA. Originally used as part of a dairy farm, the barn was built in the post and beam “English Bank” tradition around 1884. In the 1950s, the Carter family converted it into a turkey farm, but it went out of operation and has been vacant since the 1970s.
When Douglas Carter Beane, a five time TONYnominated playwright from New York, inherited the property in 1998, he wondered what to do with this structure that seemed to be a few years away from collapse and sliding down the hill, filled with turkey feathers and rusted farm equipment. He and his husband, Lewis Flinn, decided to save the structure and honor the rural community of Lake Carey. Then began five years of restoration work.
100 years of dirt and muck was cleaned out, slanted posts and beams were straightened, over 50 windows were added, electric brought in and custom light fixtures made, plumbing and state of the art ADA compliant bathrooms were added. Countless bespoke design features fill the over 7,000 sq feet of space with eclectic charm and warmth.
They floated a historic gazebo across Lake Carey and restored it to its Victorian Glory, adding an adjoining 1000-square-foot stone patio. The space is unique for weddings, concerts, art shows, theater performances, or large family gatherings.
Property Restoration Gallery
At Old Carter Barn, our goal is to make your wedding as memorable and magical as possible. We offer a lot of guidance and support to make sure that happens. Our entire team is certified wedding planners, and we include event management and day-of coordination in all of our packages.
